Monday, February 4, 2008

GTFF Bargaining in the News

If you missed it, you can catch the Emerald article about bargaining here. It's pretty accurate.

Saturday, February 2, 2008

Getting Fired Up

[Read the post before this one for a summation of the UO's offers on economics, then come back here.]

[UPDATE: When I first posted this, I relied on some back-of-the-envelope calculations that have proved less than accurate. I originally estimated that the UO spent around $13M a year on GTF compensation. I now believe that $18M is a closer figure. So, when I was using the $13M figure, I believed that the UO's economic offer of an additional $300,000 in wage compensation was 2.3% of their total outlay for GTFs. Of course, if the UO spends $18M on GTFs, then the $300,000 represents only a 1.67% increase to GTF compensation. I have corrected the post below.]

The more I think about the UO's offers, the more pissy I get. They offered a 4% raise to the minimum in the first year. According to my calculations, this will cost them about $300,000. They offered to pay $100 a term for children's health care. I estimate this will cost them about $16,000 per year. So $316,000 in new benefits.

But they proposed raising fees on aprox. 1330 GTFs by $2 per term. This is $8000 a year in money back to them. They also proposed lowering the amount of money they pay for COBRA administration by $10,000. So in their proposal, they save $18,000.

They did also offer to pick up health care increases up to 20%, but we won't know how much money that is, if any, until May at the earliest, so that's a wash for now.

So they offered to increase total GTF compensation by around $300,000. They currently spend approximately $18 million on GTF compensation (wages, fees, health care). So their proposal would increase total GTF compensation by 1.67%.

1.67%.

GTFs teach 30% of the instructional FTE on campus. GTFs do the shit academic work on campus. We grade papers, spend all night in labs, lead discussion sections, file paperwork. We do all the jobs that professors don't want to do, freeing them up for the research, conferences, and all the good parts of an academic career. The UO gets all of the shit work done for about $18 million dollars a year. That's on an institutional budget of $400,000,000.

So when they walk in and say that $300,000 and 1.67% is all they have for us -- and then pat themselves on the back for their generosity--I start to get fired up.

Hope you do, too.

Did Not See That Coming

The UO's initial offer on fees is a fee increase.

Not a huge increase mind you, $2 a term, but we'd also lose the cap on fees, so they could go up at any time. The UO suggests that if you want fees to go down you should take over the student government and vote them down.

That's right, in addition to working one third of the instructional hours at the UO, going to graduate school, getting your research done, finishing in 7 years, and trying to have some sort of life, you should also plan on running for student government. You know, a little something to do in your spare time.

Dean Linton warned me to watch my rhetoric on this issue. Which is kind of funny, because if he wanted me to watch my rhetoric, you'd think he would have come with maybe a fee decrease instead of an increase. But I will honor the man's request and watch my rhetoric.

The UO offered a fee increase for all GTFs.

If you do not earn the minimum wage or have children, your benefits in the next two years would get worse under the UO's proposals.

The UO proposed to take away the absolute cap on fees that is currently in place and replace it with a cap only on the fees they control. Your fees would go up if the ASUO votes to increase fees. (Maybe to help pay for a new arena?)

This offer sucks.

/watch

On wages, they offered to raise the minimum wages by 8% over two years. This isn't a bad offer at all. It's what they started out offering last year. It would cost them about $1 million over two years. I think. They weren't too terribly clear on how they got that figure. They basically admitted they made a semi-informed guess.

As far as wage offers go, I've seen worse. I've seen better mind you, but I have seen worse. Unfortunately, any goodwill engendered by the wage offer was more than wasted by the fee offer.

On the issue of "timely pay," the UO said "no." Oddly enough, they said no because the problem is so widespread they can't solve it for us because they can't solve it for any other employee group. Make sense? When pressed to explain or elucidate exactly which employee groups were suffering from late pay like GTFs are, the UO was unable to do so. But trust them, this is a widespread problem. Too big to be fixed. Except they're working on it. How are they working on it? They can't say.

They did come up with a creative little solution to the child care problem. They offered to knock $100 off the cost of cost of adding a kid to the health insurance. It's not the same thing and we haven't really looked at potential problems, but at least they spent more than 5 minutes thinking about this issue. Unlike, say, fees or timely pay.

So there we have it. The opening positions are staked out. Where we go from here is the fun part. The UO tries to convince us that their "million dollar offer" is that absolute best they can do. It's our job not to buy that. Actually, it's their job to convince us that their offer is pretty close to their best offer, so that we feel like any improvement to their opening offer is a "victory" for us. It is our job to stay focused on the need to eliminate fees on GTFs and not get caught up in "making a deal." Believe me, it's harder than it sounds.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Do you feel safe?

It's funny how the University can somehow find ways to look so foolish at the table. For example, they can argue that it isn't perfectly reasonable to expect that we work in a safe and healthy place, and that we have the tools and supplies needed to do the job THEY hired us to do. It's not that they don't think that these things are important in the abstract (well maybe they do and maybe they don't), but somehow they can find a way to simultaneously call us the "best and the brightest" and at the same time imply that we can't be trusted to be 'reasonable' in defining what is a safe and healthy space. "Surely" they argue "shouldn't their be some sort of objective standard by which we can say this person has made a reasonable determination that they feel unsafe." Huh, 'I feel unsafe,' now please tell me if my feelings are valid and have met the University-determined threshold so I can know if I am being 'reasonable' or not. Sounds perfectly logical to me.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

As a bargaining team member who has never done this before, I have to say last session was the most interesting one yet.  I thought our economic proposals might have generated a stir from the University's side, but somehow our non-economic proposals caused more of a commotion.  Dave has done a nice job describing it in vague terms.  Needless to say I look forward to the session(s) where some of these topic will come up again.  I would also like to mention how nice it is to have supporters come, especially when the University tries to say something outrageous.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Best and the Brightest

One of the advantages of not being over-the-top with our rhetoric or demands is that when the university goes over-the-top with their rhetoric, they look like asses. Oh, I am sure that we cross the line sometimes and I am sure that University administrators are so far removed that they honestly think that $8000 a year sounds like a perfectly reasonable wage. Our members, however, take a very different view don't believe that asking for, say fee relief, is over-the-top. But when University administrators start condescending, our members go nuts.

I think a key here is that many grad unionist are very new to the union (because of the constant turnover) and even newer to bargaining. Usually grad unionists are only familiar with unions from what they know in the popular culture and the popular culture has not been good for unions as of late, so they kind of expect the union to be all high demands, fiery rhetoric and strike talk from day one. In other words, they expect their union to be unreasonable. We very deliberately do not live up to these expectations. One of the ways we do this, of course, is by surveying our members to find out what they want from bargaining and what they think is reasonable, then not setting our opening bargaining proposals much above that. We also do a thorough job of presenting the rationale behind our proposals to our members. We say, yeah, a 10% raise sounds like a lot, but your comparators earn more, the average wage is below the poverty line, you qualify for food stamps, the UO financial aid office says it costs more than you earn to attend the university, and you do 30% of the instructional work on campus, but get only 15% of the instructional pay. We do the same for all of our proposals. We sum it up in the mantra, "Never put anything on the table you don't believe in."

So, while our proposals may ask for a lot and we may know they UO can't afford everything we ask for, the proposals make sense and they have a solid basis. The same with our rhetoric. We show that GTFs, on average, earn below the poverty line. We say that it is shameful that the UO cannot make sure that all of its employees are not living in poverty. We don't dwell on it and we don't accuse the actual people across from us as being at fault or not caring about this. Hell, I want them to agree with me that it is bad and help us fix it. What the GTFF does not do is make it out like GTFs are starving to death. GTFs are poor--yes. GTFs struggle financially--yes. GTFs make difficult financial choices--yes. GTFs are living in cardboard boxes under overpasses--no. We don't compare ourselves to sweatshop labor. We religiously avoid references to slavery. We keep third-world workers out of our bargaining table presentations.

We do all of these things so that when the University decides to unleash a little sarcasm, blithely dismiss our proposals, condescend to the point of mockery, then they, as I said before, tend to look like asses. And, as much fun as that can be, the important thing is that it gets the membership on our side and fired up. It literally can convert a union skeptic into a leader in one afternoon. And all those people go out and tell their friends and the next thing you know your union is organizing. We've all heard that the bosses are the best organizers. Definitely true, and that's why we love having members come to bargaining, because you never know when the other side is going to go ahead and do all your organizing work for you.

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Long time, no post

It has been a long time, but bargaining really only got cooking last Friday.

The GTFF presented our economic proposals to the UO. It went about as can be expected. We gave them a little presentation, they asked questions, we gave them our proposals. It's possible that some of you think that perhaps bargaining is a no stop give-and-take of conversation studded with proposal, counter-proposal, and further counter-proposals until the two sides come to some agreement. It may work that way somewhere, but it does not work that way here at the UO. Here we propose, they caucus to ponder, they return to tell us that they need more pondering time, then next time we see them they inform us that our proposals were unacceptable. Well, sometimes they counter propose, but it is not really a two way engagement of ideas/rhetoric. We do the same to them though. It can be really frustrating to throw out four or five really good reasons why your proposal makes good sense, only to never have any of those ideas engaged with. But like I say, we do it to them as well, so I can't complain.

Our economic proposals were quite hefty. We asked for a lot. (but then GTFs deserve a lot, natch.)

For wages, we asked for 10% raises over two years. This is what GTFs got in the last contract and the contract in 2002 (I think it was 2002, prove me wrong). So, for us, a 10% raise request is not a huge deal. It may be to the UO, but not for us.

On fees, we went for it all. Complete fee relief. All fees for GTFs, gone. I must say the UO's reaction to this proposal was muted at best. I had hinted earlier in the session that it was coming, but I expected more out of them than the placidity than I got. Maybe that means they are already on board.

We also asked for a child care benefit. I gave some impassioned words about how we have had language in the contract for the last seven-and-a-half years where the University and the Union have totally agreed that child care is totally important and something must be done, but nothing has gotten done. I vowed that this would end this year and something would get done.

All-in-all, we asked for something more than a million and something less than 2 million dollars in new/expanded benefits. The UO currently spends roughly $14 million a year on GTFs, so a 10% or so increase. Not over the top.

We also proposed a neat little solution to the problem of GTFs getting paid late. We proposed that if a GTF signs his or her contract 10 working days before the start of the term and that GTF does not receive their check on time, then the GTF gets an automatic $100 credit in their student account and another $100 every 5 days the check is not available.

This Friday, we offer the rest of our proposals, then on February 1st the UO responds with their economic proposals. Keep an eye on the GTFF webpage for room and time.

Here's a copy of our presentation to the UO. This information helped inform our proposals.

Article 21 [Salary]

Almost there ~ Stay on target

Background facts:

Based on D-list given to the GTFF on 10-5-2007

Month

Term

Academic Yr

Average GTF Minimum Wage

$923.65

$2,770.95

$8,312.85

Average Wage

$1,142.69

$3,428.07

$10,284.21

Average Minimum FTE

.3673

Average FTE

.4029

GTFs earning minimum

558

GTFs earning above minimum

529

1. Comparator Data

GTF wages are roughly 9.5% behind those of our official comparators.

[Insert chart here] [Chart won't insert] [You'll have to trust me]


2. Poverty

The average GTF earns $10,284 or just above the poverty line. The average GTF earning the minimum wage earns $8,313 or $1897 less than the poverty line.

2007 HHS Poverty Guidelines

Persons
in Family or Household

48 Contiguous
States and D.C.

Alaska

Hawaii

1

$10,210

$12,770

$11,750

2

13,690

17,120

15,750

3

17,170

21,470

19,750

4

20,650

25,820

23,750

SOURCE: Federal Register, Vol. 72, No. 15, January 24, 2007, pp. 3147–3148 and http://aspe.hhs.gov/poverty/07poverty.shtml


3. Food stamps

According to the State of Oregon’s DHS Food Stamp Calculator -- https://apps.dhs.state.or.us/fsestimate/ -- a single GTF who earns the minimum wage, pays $450 a month in rent and pays his or her own utilities would qualify for an estimated $93 a month in food stamps.

4. UO calculations

Based on information found at http://financialaid.uoregon.edu/Cost.htm

Monthly

Academic Year

Full Year

Off-Campus Housing

Monthly: Rent, $440, Food, $293, Utilities, $139

$872

$7,848

$10,464

Books and Supplies

$87.50

$1,050

$1,050

Personal Expenses

$277

$2,496

$3,328

Minimum Fees

$69

$618

$618

Total

$1,306

$12,012

$15,460

UO Recommended Laptop (Law students)

$1,650

The average GTF earns $163 less per month than the UO estimated cost of attendance. The average GTF who earns the minimum earns $382 less per month than the UO’s estimated cost of attendance. The average GTF who earns the minimum earns about half of the yearly cost of living for attending the UO.

5. Ratio of labor to pay

Based on information from 2006 found at: http://rm.uoregon.edu/pi_2006_sum_report

03-04

04-05

05-06

GTF FTE

389.4

397.1

394.1

Total Instructional FTE

1226.3

1231.2

1242.2

31.75%

32.25%

31.73%

GTF Salary

$8,975,282

$9,174,258

$9,286,078

Total Instructional Salaries

$59,640,816

$60,096,489

$63,792,741

15.05%

15.27%

14.56%

Article 22[Fees]

Onerous ~ Burdensome

1. Membership

Fee relief was voted the number #1 goal of the membership of the GTFF in every survey we did.

In the past year, many departments that did not raise their wages because they did not have to. This means that hundreds of GTFs saw no increase in benefits, despite the fact that inflation caused real wages to go down by 3% or so.

2. Give backs

GTFs face a myriad of fees:

Type of Fee

Fee

Resource Fee

$206

Matriculation Fee

$250

Studio-based Art & Architecture Fee

$125

Non Studio-based Art & Architecture Fee

$75

Computer Science

$125

LCB

$600

Music

$100

Education

$50

Source: http://www.ous.edu/dept/budget/files/AY07%20Fee%20Book_Rev_072507.pdf

Our estimation is that GTFs pay roughly $1,033,000 in fees to the UO every year. These fees represent a return to the UO of approximately 11% of the total salary earned by GTFs.

GTFs can pay as much as $2668 a year in fees alone.

The minimum amount of fees a GTF pays is $618 per year. This represents 6% of the average GTF’s annual salary and 7.4% of the annual salary of a GTF who earns the average minimum wage.

Fall fees are particularly burdensome because the first check most GTFs collect are half-checks. A new GTF who earns the minimum average would have a fee bill of at least $456 due October 1, while collecting a $462 check.

3. Fee Reform

The undergraduate deal to roll some fees into tuition did not include graduate students. Graduate students were excluded because rolling graduate fees into tuition would not be “revenue neutral.”